The Profit Matrix: A Consultant’s Guide to Structuring Profitability in Case Interviews

The Profit Matrix: A Consultant’s Guide to Structuring Profitability in Case Interviews

If you're preparing for a consulting interview, you’ll likely come across profitability cases. The Profit Matrix is a powerful framework to break down the core drivers of profit and structure your analysis logically. Whether you’re tackling a case about a struggling business or identifying revenue opportunities for a client, this method will help you craft a clear, data-driven response.


The Simple Profit Formula: A Consultant’s Go-To Approach

At its core, profit is simply:

Profit = Revenue - Costs

In an interview, structuring your approach properly is key. Let’s break it down into its two main components: Revenue(money coming in) and Costs (money going out), and understand where optimizations can be made.


1. Revenue: The Growth Lever

Revenue is the total income a business generates. The basic formula:

Revenue = Price per Unit x Nr of Units Sold

How to Approach Revenue in a Case Interview

  • Ask about pricing strategy: Can the company increase prices without losing customers?

  • Assess volume growth: Are there opportunities to increase sales through marketing, expansion, or partnerships?

  • Explore new revenue streams: Can the company introduce complementary products or services?

Example: Consulting Interview Question

Client: A red-light therapy studio is experiencing declining profits. How would you analyze its revenue streams?

  • Current price per session = 22$

  • Number of sessions booked per month = 500

Total Revenue = 22 x 500 = 11 000$

Possible solutions:

  • Introduce premium-priced packages

  • Upsell memberships or bundle services

  • Improve marketing to increase session bookings


2. Cost Analysis: Finding Efficiency Gains

Costs are divided into Fixed Costs and Variable Costs.

Fixed Costs: The Baseline Expenses

These don’t change with output and need to be optimized carefully.

  • Rent

  • Staff salaries

  • Marketing

For the therapy studio:

  • Rent = 2,000$

  • Staff salary = 3,000$

  • Marketing = 500$

Total Fixed Costs = 5,500$

Consulting Considerations:

  • Can we renegotiate rent or relocate to a lower-cost space?

  • Is staff utilization optimized?

  • Can marketing be shifted to more cost-effective digital strategies?

Variable Costs: Expenses That Scale with Sales

  • Electricity per session

  • Supplies per session

Example:

  • Electricity per session = 2$

  • Total sessions = 500

Total Variable Cost = 2 x 500 = 1 000$

Consulting Considerations:

  • Are there supplier contracts that can be renegotiated?

  • Can process efficiencies reduce waste?

  • Can the business switch to lower-cost materials or utilities?


Structuring a Profitability Case in an Interview

When faced with a profitability case, structure your approach as follows:

  1. Clarify the Problem: What specific aspect of profitability is declining—revenue, costs, or both?

  2. Break Down Revenue: Assess price, volume, and possible new revenue streams.

  3. Analyze Costs: Identify fixed vs. variable costs and look for optimization opportunities.

  4. Synthesize Insights: Recommend solutions based on the biggest impact areas.

  5. Prioritize Execution: Identify quick wins and long-term strategies.


Final Thoughts: Nail Your Consulting Interview

The Profit Matrix isn’t just a theoretical framework—it’s an essential consulting tool. By mastering this breakdown, you can confidently approach profitability cases with a structured and logical mindset.

Next time you get a case about declining profits, take a deep breath and walk through this matrix step by step. That’s how consultants think, and that’s how you’ll impress your interviewers.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.